[ga-abuse] Complaint list, with M1 judgment passed

[Harald Tveit Alvestrand <harald@Alvestrand.no>]

Here are the 41 cases.
What took longest was to find the archive references....sigh.

I suggest that each of you decide to take on one person as M2, post a 
proposal for a judgment letter to the list, and wait 24 hours.
With luck, we can be through with the backlog of cases by Wednesday.

Please use case numbers when discussing specific cases.

                   Harald
Case: 1
Date: Apr 5
From: William Walsh
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00217.html
Injured party: William Walsh
Injury: "thinly veiled personal attack"
Comment: Was held over due to Eric being an election candidate
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

Case: 2
Date: Apr 5
From: William Walsh
Against: JessWest@aol.com
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00218.html
Injured party: Jeff Williams
Injury: "chewing too much peyote"
Comment: Warning sent (on-list)
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning (executed)

Case: 3
Date: Apr 8
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00262.html
         http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00273.html
Injured party: Patrick Corliss
Injury: "demands, personal insults, threats and falsehoods"
Comment: candidate
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

case: 4
Date: Apr 8
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00277.html
Injured party: Patrick Corliss
Injury: "slur upon my character"
Comment: candidate
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

Case: 5
Date: Apr 8
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00279.html
Injured party: Patrick Corliss
Injury: Quoting Jeff Williams (currently banned)
Comment: candidate
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore, not a violation

Case: 6
Date: Apr 10
From: Dave Crocker
Against: Chris Ambler
Message: Not quoted
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "claim that my goal is to divert discussion"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

Case: 7
Date: Apr 10
From: Kent Crispin
Against: Roeland Meyer
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00456.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "Your evil-implication, is as usual, perverse and misleading."
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 8
Date: Apr 10
From: Kent Crispin
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00443.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker, Kent Crispin
Injury: Character attack
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

Case: 9
Date: Apr 11
From: Dave Crocker
Against: Patrick Corliss
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00583.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "Your logic never makes sense"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore

Case: 10
Date: Apr 11
From: Dave Crocker
Against: Chris Ambler
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00563.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "Call it like it is, Nero"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 11
Date: Apr 14
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Dave Crocker
Injury: 14 posts in one day
Comment: Warning sent, and acknowledged.
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning (done)

Case: 12
Date: Apr 14
From: Dave Crocker
Against: PacificRoot Hostmaster
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00739.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "..your payrolled nonsense"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 13
Date: Apr 14
From: Joe Kelsey
Against: Patrick Corliss
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00762.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "...hired gun"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 14
Date: Apr 14
From: Joe Kelsey
Against: Patrick Corliss
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00763.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker
Injury: "paid agent provocateur etcetera"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 15
Date: Apr 15
From: Dave Crocker, Joe Kelsey (2 complaints)
Against: PacificRoot Hostmaster
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00798.html
Injured party: Dave Crocker, John Charles Broomfield
Injury: "stupid" "confidence man"
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 16
Date: Apr 16
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William X. Walsh
Injury: too many postings in one day (Apr 13, 15 and 17)
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Suspend (executed)

Case: 17
Date: Apr 17
From: William X. Walsh
Against: Patrick Corliss
Injury: Posting of private message with inappropriate content
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00927.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (relevant to GA business, no rule against particular infraction)

Case: 18
Date: Apr 17
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William X. Walsh
Injury: Posting of private message
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00925.html (uncertain)
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (same as above)

Case: 19
Date: Apr 17
From: Joop Ternstra
Against: William X. Walsh
Injury: Threats in message (from case 17)
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (did not take place primarily on list)

Case: 20
Date: Apr 17
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Kent Crispin, William X. Walsh, Dave Crocker, David Farrar, 
Injury: Personal attacks against GA alternate chair
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: These should be judged individually. Please resubmit (or drop).

Case: 21
Date: Apr 18
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Dave Crocker
Injury: Accusation of slander
Messasge: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00962.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 22
Date: Apr 18
From: Danny Younger
Against: William Walsh
Injury: Mass posting
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Suspension (executed)

Case: 23
From: Joop Ternstra
Against: Dave Crocker
Injury: Ad hominem attack on Michael Froomkin
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg00982.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 24
From: Joop Ternstra
Against: William Walsh
Injury: Threat against the GA list
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: ignore (reaction to case 22 suspension, did not arrive on list)

Case: 25
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William Walsh
Injury: Flaming and implied threat
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (suspended)

Case: 26
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Injury: Flaming, insults and personal abuse
   "there must be restrictions placed upon the obscene
   use of position  that mr. Corliss is trying to manipulate"
   violates both decorum and the English language.
Messasge: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01032.html
Judgment: Suspension for 2 weeks (together with all the other cases)
M1: Harald Alvestrand

Case: 27
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Jeff Williams
Injury: Personal attack
Judgment: Ignore (messages did not appear on GA list)

Case: 28
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William Walsh
Injury: Accusations of position abuse
Judgment: Ignore (suspended)

Case: 29
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01039.html
Injury: Personal attack, insults and slander
Judgment: Suspension (together with 26)

Case: 30
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William Walsh
Injury: Personal attacks, insults and slander
Judgment: Ignore (suspended)

Case: 30
Date: Apr 18
From: Eric Dierker
Against: Patrick Corliss
Injury: Threat of abuse of monitor power
Judgment: Ignore (already suspended for 26 and 29; power holders must be
   especially careful with regard to silencing complaints about power abuse)

Case: 31
Date: APr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Jeff Williams
Injury: Personal attacks, insults and slander
Judgment: Ignore (suspended)

Case: 32
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Injury: Personal attacks, insults and slander
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01046.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Pass over because already suspended on 26 & 29

Case: 33
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Injury: "planned to set up the destruction of the DNSO"
Note: This message (starting "CAN ANYONE IN THIS GROUP SPELL CAPTURE") was
  extensively cross-posted, so did not appear on GA list.
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (not on GA list)

Case: 34
Date: Apr 19
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Injury: Various ("on a board which is at war with ICANN")
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01050.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: marginal (strong language, lack of clarity)

Case: 35
Date: Apr 20
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Eric Dierker
Injury: Various ("hiding things which are not in the open")
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01069.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Can be included in grounds for suspension

Case: 36
Date: Apr 21
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: William X. Walsh
Injury: Insults and accusations of power abuse
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Ignore (off list)

Case: 37
Date: Apr 22
From: Joe Kelsey
Against: John Palmer
Injury: Slanderous charges against Kent Crispin
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01189.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 38
Date: Apr 23
From: Kent Crispin
Against: Roeland Meyer
Injury: Insults, accusations of totaliaranism
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01197.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 39
Date: Apr 23
From: Jeff Williams
Against: Kent Crispin
Injury: Fake posting in his name
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01133.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning (executed)

Case: 40
Date: Apr 25
From: Patrick Corliss
Against: Sotiris Sotiroppoulos
Injury: Personal attack ("vindicative nature")
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01248.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning

Case: 41
Date: Apr 25
From: Sotiris Sotiropoulos
Against: Danny Younger
Injury: Personal attack ("your comment...serves vindictiveness")
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01242.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Jugment: Dismissed (factually correct statement)

case: 42
Date: Apr 29
From: Leah Gallegos, Bruce James
Against: Kent Crispin
Injury: Insult ("captured by delusional people")
Message: http://www.dnso.org/clubpublic/ga/Arc07/msg01369.html
M1: Harald Alvestrand
Judgment: Warning