ICANN/DNSO


Full record of vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council UDRP Task Force, July 2001

Wednesday 25 July 2001, 22:00 Paris time.

Re: b07

Vote by the GA to designate its representative to the Names Council UDRP Task Force

cf. http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.DNSO-GA-UdrpTF.html

The vote was conducted by the DNSO Secretariat using Instant Runoff Vote according to the Election Rules adopted by the GA and published in: http://www.dnso.org/dnso/notes/2001.GA-chair-election-rules-v0.2.html.

The members to the Watchdog Committee in 2001 election are:

The time for the vote was:

Begins: Tuesday 17 July 2001, 07:00 UTC, 09:00 CET (Paris),
Ends: Tuesday 24 July 2001, 07:00 UTC, 09:00 CET (Paris)

A. The final result:

Dan Steinberg is elected.

B. Information about ballots received:

  1. Number of ballots received: 73

  2. One (1) ballot empty:

         1. b07:K3756Z
    

    which adds to number of valid ballots, and increases majority requirement in the first step.

  3. Besides ballots we received fourteen (14) Delivery-Reports:

         1  b07:K637aZ
         2  b07:Kb852Z
         3  b07:Kce6fZ
         4  b07:K7e3cZ
         5  b07:Kb876Z
         6  b07:Ke051Z
         7  b07:Ka34dZ
         8  b07:K34b3Z
         9  b07:Kb935Z
        10  b07:K27fcZ
        11  b07:K85e9Z
        12  b07:K835eZ
        13  b07:Kb890Z
        14  b07:K9ab2Z
    
  4. Two (2) voters sent multiple ballots, the last overrides the others:

         1. b07:Kd57eZ
         2. b07:K4348Z
    

C. Adjustements:

Besides trashing HTML format, the following adjustements were made:

     1. b07:Kf899Z, line END__: completed
     2. b07:K7130Z, line END__: completed

D. Three (3) "x" adjustements:

Three (3) received ballots were with only one candidate marked, not with "1" but with "x".

The Secretariat tends to consider these ballots valid, "x" replaced by "1" for results calculation.

     1. b07:Kd1d6Z:[x] Chris McElroy
     2. b07:K3297Z:[x] Rod Dixon
     3. b07:K37b7Z:[x] Chris McElroy

E. Full public record:

Ballot sent with  choices
           b07:[ ] Chris McElroy
           b07:[ ] Rod Dixon
           b07:[ ] Dan Steinberg

Electorate of 333 persons, casting one vote each
Ballots received from 73 persons (sorted by arrival time)
     Jeffrey Williams
     William X. Walsh
     Adam Peake
     Pascal Bernhard
     Detlef Laub
     Giacomo Catenazzi
     Jean-François C. (Jefsey) Morfin
     Guy Millward
     Steffen Goewe
     Harold Burstyn
     Jonathan Weinberg
     Dave Geurs
     Dirk Lorenz
     ken stubbs
     Joe Gluza
     Jocelyn Nadeau
     Alexander Svensson
     Michael Gendron, Ph.D.
     Hartmut Richard Glaser
     Camron Johnson
     Marc Schneiders
     Karl E. Peters
     Robin Lynn Miller
     Gary Osbourne
     Sloan Gaon
     Michaela Gerberich
     Joanna Lane
     Timothy Denton
     Gerald St. Amand
     Bruce James
     Michael Haffely
     Kendall Dawson
     Sotiris Sotiropoulos
     Chippu Abraham
     Steve Parrish
     Erick Iriarte
     Meinrad Nell
     David  Heemann
     Frederic Wilf
     Anupam Chander
     Seth Goodman
     Paul Svensson
     David Farrar
     Loic Damilaville
     Richard W. Kroon
     Scott Hollenbeck
     David Ervin
     Leah Gallegos
     Kristal Preschern
     Hugh Blair
     Rod Dixon
     Rita Kershaw
     Cindy Merry
     Michael Miller
     Joop Teernstra
     Kristy McKee
     Nestor Requeno
     Earl Heather
     Chuck Gomes
     Jason Graff
     Glen de Saint Gery
     Ellen Rony
     Peter de Blanc
     Cees (Cornelis) Rindmarsch
     Dany Vandromme
     Roeland Meyer
     Michael F. McNulty
     Chris McElroy
     Patrick Corliss
     Guillaume Laucournet
     Kent Crispin
     Alberto Pellizzari
     Annie Renard

-------------------------------------------------------------
Now selecting the first 
-------------------------------------------------------------
Casted votes (sorted by personal code)
  K112fZ : 1,3,2,
  K1158Z : 2,3,1,
  K129fZ : 0,1,0,
  K130bZ : 2,1,0,
  K16a0Z : 1,2,3,
  K1833Z : 2,1,3,
  K1b18Z : 2,0,1,
  K1c82Z : 3,2,1,
  K1fe8Z : 3,2,1,
  K2091Z : 1,3,2,
  K20faZ : 0,1,2,
  K2267Z : 3,2,1,
  K263cZ : 0,0,1,
  K2d11Z : 0,0,1,
  K2e77Z : 2,1,3,
  K3297Z : 0,1,0,
  K32cfZ : 0,1,2,
  K3327Z : 1,3,2,
  K3756Z : 0,0,0,
  K37b7Z : 1,0,0,
  K4290Z : 1,3,2,
  K4348Z : 1,0,0,
  K4a12Z : 1,0,0,
  K4f36Z : 3,2,1,
  K61d3Z : 1,0,0,
  K676dZ : 2,1,0,
  K6c03Z : 1,2,3,
  K6e51Z : 0,0,1,
  K7130Z : 3,2,1,
  K747eZ : 0,2,1,
  K7934Z : 3,1,2,
  K7968Z : 3,2,1,
  K7c3aZ : 2,0,1,
  K7edbZ : 1,0,0,
  K8157Z : 2,3,1,
  K8a42Z : 2,1,3,
  K8d8cZ : 1,0,0,
  K8e00Z : 1,2,3,
  K8e69Z : 0,0,1,
  K9534Z : 0,1,2,
  K9c5bZ : 2,1,3,
  Ka05bZ : 1,2,3,
  Ka686Z : 1,3,2,
  Kb08bZ : 1,2,3,
  Kb335Z : 0,1,0,
  Kb3afZ : 2,3,1,
  Kb8f3Z : 1,3,2,
  KbecaZ : 0,2,1,
  Kc7eeZ : 2,3,1,
  Kcd32Z : 0,0,1,
  Kce4bZ : 2,1,0,
  Kcfe4Z : 3,2,1,
  Kd1d6Z : 1,0,0,
  Kd382Z : 1,0,0,
  Kd57eZ : 1,3,2,
  Kd62cZ : 1,0,0,
  Kd7d4Z : 0,2,1,
  Kd99eZ : 0,1,0,
  Kd9abZ : 2,3,1,
  Kda3bZ : 1,2,3,
  Kdc3dZ : 2,3,1,
  Ke4fdZ : 1,3,2,
  Ke8ceZ : 3,1,2,
  Kec31Z : 0,0,1,
  Kf032Z : 0,1,2,
  Kf065Z : 0,0,1,
  Kf320Z : 0,0,1,
  Kf659Z : 0,1,0,
  Kf899Z : 2,3,1,
  Kfa93Z : 3,1,2,
  KfbccZ : 2,0,1,
  Kfc8dZ : 0,0,1,
  Kffb7Z : 3,1,2,
Now 73 valid ballots

Public results 
73 BALLOTS => Majority = 37
 
    Nb votes for Rank:     0,  1,  2,  3,   in %:  0,  1,  2,  3,
Chris McElroy             22, 23, 17, 11,         30, 32, 23, 15,
Rod Dixon                 22, 20, 16, 15,         30, 27, 22, 21,
Dan Steinberg             18, 29, 16, 10,         25, 40, 22, 14,
Total :                   62, 72, 49, 36, (219)

ROUND 1 STEP 1 : Dan Steinberg has 29 rank 1 ballots
he does not have the majority
The lowest score is Rod Dixon with 20 rank 1 ballots


Discarding Rod Dixon :
  K112fZ : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  K1158Z : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K129fZ : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  K130bZ : 2,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K16a0Z : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K1833Z : 2,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K1b18Z : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K1c82Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K1fe8Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K2091Z : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  K20faZ : 0,x,2, 0,x,1,
  K2267Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K263cZ : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  K2d11Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  K2e77Z : 2,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K3297Z : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  K32cfZ : 0,x,2, 0,x,1,
  K3327Z : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  K3756Z : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  K37b7Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K4290Z : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  K4348Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K4a12Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K4f36Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K61d3Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K676dZ : 2,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K6c03Z : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K6e51Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  K7130Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K747eZ : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  K7934Z : 3,x,2, 2,x,1,
  K7968Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K7c3aZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K7edbZ : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K8157Z : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  K8a42Z : 2,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K8d8cZ : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  K8e00Z : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  K8e69Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  K9534Z : 0,x,2, 0,x,1,
  K9c5bZ : 2,x,3, 1,x,2,
  Ka05bZ : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  Ka686Z : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  Kb08bZ : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  Kb335Z : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  Kb3afZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kb8f3Z : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  KbecaZ : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kc7eeZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kcd32Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kce4bZ : 2,x,0, 1,x,0,
  Kcfe4Z : 3,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kd1d6Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  Kd382Z : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  Kd57eZ : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  Kd62cZ : 1,x,0, 1,x,0,
  Kd7d4Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kd99eZ : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  Kd9abZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kda3bZ : 1,x,3, 1,x,2,
  Kdc3dZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Ke4fdZ : 1,x,2, 1,x,2,
  Ke8ceZ : 3,x,2, 2,x,1,
  Kec31Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kf032Z : 0,x,2, 0,x,1,
  Kf065Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kf320Z : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kf659Z : 0,x,0, 0,x,0, Ballot discarded
  Kf899Z : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kfa93Z : 3,x,2, 2,x,1,
  KfbccZ : 2,x,1, 2,x,1,
  Kfc8dZ : 0,x,1, 0,x,1,
  Kffb7Z : 3,x,2, 2,x,1,
Now 67 valid ballots

Casted votes (sorted by personal code)
  K112fZ : 1,x,2,
  K1158Z : 2,x,1,
  K130bZ : 1,x,0,
  K16a0Z : 1,x,2,
  K1833Z : 1,x,2,
  K1b18Z : 2,x,1,
  K1c82Z : 2,x,1,
  K1fe8Z : 2,x,1,
  K2091Z : 1,x,2,
  K20faZ : 0,x,1,
  K2267Z : 2,x,1,
  K263cZ : 0,x,1,
  K2d11Z : 0,x,1,
  K2e77Z : 1,x,2,
  K32cfZ : 0,x,1,
  K3327Z : 1,x,2,
  K37b7Z : 1,x,0,
  K4290Z : 1,x,2,
  K4348Z : 1,x,0,
  K4a12Z : 1,x,0,
  K4f36Z : 2,x,1,
  K61d3Z : 1,x,0,
  K676dZ : 1,x,0,
  K6c03Z : 1,x,2,
  K6e51Z : 0,x,1,
  K7130Z : 2,x,1,
  K747eZ : 0,x,1,
  K7934Z : 2,x,1,
  K7968Z : 2,x,1,
  K7c3aZ : 2,x,1,
  K7edbZ : 1,x,0,
  K8157Z : 2,x,1,
  K8a42Z : 1,x,2,
  K8d8cZ : 1,x,0,
  K8e00Z : 1,x,2,
  K8e69Z : 0,x,1,
  K9534Z : 0,x,1,
  K9c5bZ : 1,x,2,
  Ka05bZ : 1,x,2,
  Ka686Z : 1,x,2,
  Kb08bZ : 1,x,2,
  Kb3afZ : 2,x,1,
  Kb8f3Z : 1,x,2,
  KbecaZ : 0,x,1,
  Kc7eeZ : 2,x,1,
  Kcd32Z : 0,x,1,
  Kce4bZ : 1,x,0,
  Kcfe4Z : 2,x,1,
  Kd1d6Z : 1,x,0,
  Kd382Z : 1,x,0,
  Kd57eZ : 1,x,2,
  Kd62cZ : 1,x,0,
  Kd7d4Z : 0,x,1,
  Kd9abZ : 2,x,1,
  Kda3bZ : 1,x,2,
  Kdc3dZ : 2,x,1,
  Ke4fdZ : 1,x,2,
  Ke8ceZ : 2,x,1,
  Kec31Z : 0,x,1,
  Kf032Z : 0,x,1,
  Kf065Z : 0,x,1,
  Kf320Z : 0,x,1,
  Kf899Z : 2,x,1,
  Kfa93Z : 2,x,1,
  KfbccZ : 2,x,1,
  Kfc8dZ : 0,x,1,
  Kffb7Z : 2,x,1,
Now 67 valid ballots

Public results 
67 BALLOTS => Majority = 34
 
    Nb votes for Rank:     0,  1,  2,  3,   in %:  0,  1,  2,  3,
Chris McElroy             16, 30, 21,  0,         24, 45, 31,  0,
Discarded                  0,  0,  0,  0,          0,  0,  0,  0,
Dan Steinberg             12, 37, 18,  0,         18, 55, 27,  0,
Total :                   28, 67, 39,  0, (134)

ROUND 1 STEP 2 : Dan Steinberg has 37 rank 1 ballots
he has the majority : he is selected 

--
End


Information from:
© DNSO Secretariat